Qazi Forex Tips logoQazi Forex Tips
Sawal Jawab · Entries

Sold the breakdown, but TP only came after a retest and a double top: why?

A member sold right at a trendline breakdown. Price did reach the target, but only after coming back twice and building a double top first. Was the entry valid, and why did the target not come on the first move down? Dr. Qazi explains, and shows the entry that avoids the stress.

Breakdown retest and double top infographic: rising trendline breaks, the entry on the break is marked, price retests the broken level twice forming a double top, the better entry is after the double top with the stop above it, then price falls to the target; points: weak break candle, nearby support, double top confirmation, SL above the double top
Break hote hi entry ke bajaye retest ka wait. Double top par entry, SL us ke upar.
The question from the group

Kya yeh entry valid hai ya nahi? Agar valid hai to is ka TP first breakdown mein kyun nahi aaya? Do dafa retrace kar ke double top banaya aur phir neeche aa kar TP hit kiya.

Dr. Qazi Abdul Basit
Dr. Qazi's answerIn Urdu, as answered in the group

پہلے بریک ڈاؤن پر ٹی پی کیوں نہیں آیا؟

جی، انٹری کا آئیڈیا ٹھیک تھا، ٹرینڈ لائن بریک ہوئی اور سیل کا موقع بنا۔ لیکن پہلے بریک ڈاؤن پر ٹی پی اس لیے نہیں آیا:

1۔ بریک ڈاؤن والی کینڈل مضبوط مومینٹم کینڈل نہیں تھی، اور تھوڑا نیچے ہی پچھلا سپورٹ موجود تھا۔ ایسی صورت میں مارکیٹ اکثر پہلے واپس آ کر ٹوٹی ہوئی ٹرینڈ لائن اور لیول کو ری ٹیسٹ کرتی ہے۔

2۔ آپ کی انٹری بریک ہوتے ہی تھی، اس لیے ری ٹیسٹ کے دوران آپ کو دباؤ برداشت کرنا پڑا۔

3۔ دو بار ری ٹیسٹ کے بعد جو ڈبل ٹاپ بنا، وہی اصل کنفرمیشن تھی کہ سیلرز کنٹرول میں ہیں۔ وہاں سے لوئر ہائی بنا اور مارکیٹ ٹی پی تک گئی۔

بہتر طریقہ یہ ہے کہ بریک کے بعد ری ٹیسٹ کا ویٹ کریں۔ ری ٹیسٹ پر ریجیکشن کینڈل یا ڈبل ٹاپ بنے تو انٹری لیں اور سٹاپ لاس ڈبل ٹاپ کے اوپر رکھیں۔ اس سے سٹاپ لاس بھی چھوٹا ہو گا اور ٹریڈ میں ٹینشن بھی کم ہو گی۔

The idea was right, the timing was early

The trendline broke and a sell made sense, so the trade idea was valid. The target was eventually hit. The problem was the entry timing: selling the moment the line broke meant sitting through two pullbacks before the move came.

Why the first breakdown did not reach the target

  1. The break candle was weak. A strong break is made by a momentum candle: a large body closing near its low. A small or wicky break candle shows the sellers are not yet fully in control.
  2. There was support just below. A previous support level sat a short distance under the break. Price often bounces from such a level and comes back to test the broken trendline.
  3. Broken levels get retested. Old support often acts as resistance on the way back, and the market tests it, sometimes more than once, before moving on. See trendlines and the breakout and retest strategy.

The double top was the real confirmation

After two retests, price formed a double top below the broken line, then a lower high. That showed buyers had failed twice at the same place, and that sellers were now in control. From there the market went to the target.

The better entry

  1. Let the trendline or level break.
  2. Wait for price to come back and retest it.
  3. Enter when a rejection candle or a double top forms at the retest.
  4. Place the stop loss just above the double top.
  5. Target the next support or liquidity level below.

This gives a smaller stop, a better risk to reward, and much less stress during the trade. If no retest comes and price falls straight away, let the trade go; another setup will come. Many failed breaks are covered in false breakouts: how to spot them.

Khulasa (Roman Urdu / Hindi)

  • Entry ka idea theek tha: trendline break hui aur sell ka mauqa bana.
  • Pehle breakdown par TP is liye nahi aaya: break candle kamzor thi aur neeche qareeb support tha, is liye market ne retest kiya.
  • Break hote hi entry thi, is liye retest ke dauran pressure bardasht karna para.
  • Do retest ke baad double top asal confirmation thi ke sellers control mein hain.
  • Behtar: break ke baad retest ka wait, rejection ya double top par entry, SL double top ke upar.

Questions

Should I enter as soon as a trendline breaks?

It is often better to wait for the retest of the broken line and enter on a rejection candle or double top. The stop is smaller and the trade is less stressful.

Why does price retest a broken trendline?

Broken support often acts as resistance, and when the break candle is weak or there is support just below, price commonly comes back to test the level before continuing.

Where should the stop loss go after a retest entry?

Just above the double top or the rejection candle that formed at the retest.

How do I know a breakout is strong?

A strong breakout is made by a momentum candle with a large body closing near its extreme, with room before the next level.

اکثر پوچھے جانے والے سوال

کیا ٹرینڈ لائن بریک ہوتے ہی انٹری لیں؟

بہتر ہے ری ٹیسٹ کا ویٹ کریں اور ریجیکشن یا ڈبل ٹاپ پر انٹری لیں۔

مارکیٹ ری ٹیسٹ کیوں کرتی ہے؟

کمزور بریک کینڈل اور قریب سپورٹ کی وجہ سے مارکیٹ اکثر ٹوٹے ہوئے لیول کو ٹیسٹ کرتی ہے۔

سٹاپ لاس کہاں؟

ڈبل ٹاپ کے اوپر۔

Aksar Pooche Jane Wale Sawal (Roman Urdu / Hindi)

Trendline break hote hi entry lein?

Behtar hai retest ka wait karein.

TP pehle breakdown mein kyun nahi aaya?

Break candle kamzor thi aur neeche support tha.

SL kahan rakhein?

Double top ke upar.

Learn more

Have a question of your own, or a chart you want checked? Post it with your reasoning in our free Facebook group.

Join the free group

Education only, not financial advice. Trading forex, Gold and CFDs carries a high risk of loss. Spreads, leverage and contract sizes differ by broker; check your own broker's specifications.