Main 1 saal se gold par trading kar raha hoon, still not profitable. Profit bhi karta hoon lekin 2-3 din mein wapis market ko de deta hoon loss karke. Main sirf support/resistance aur OB par trade leta hoon, cent account hai mera. Please thora detail mein guide karein.
پرافٹ کر کے واپس کیوں دے دیتے ہیں؟
وعلیکم السلام بھائی، profit کرتا ہوں پھر 2، 3 دن میں واپس دے دیتا ہوں، یہ تقریباً ہر اس trader کی کہانی ہے جو ایک سال کے مرحلے میں ہوتا ہے۔ اچھی خبر یہ ہے کہ اس کا مطلب ہے اپ کی entries میں دم ہے، مسئلہ عام طور پر strategy میں نہیں بلکہ ان تین جگہوں پر ہوتا ہے:
1۔ ہارنے والی trades بڑی، جیتنے والی چھوٹی: profit جلدی بند کر دیتے ہیں اور loss کو واپس آ جائے گی سوچ کر چلاتے رہتے ہیں۔ حل: ہر trade میں SL پہلے سے fix، اور TP کم از کم SL کا دوگنا (RR 1:2)۔ SL کو کبھی پیچھے نہ ہٹائیں۔
2۔ profit کے بعد lot بڑا ہو جانا یا trades زیادہ ہو جانا: جیتنے کے بعد اعتماد بڑھتا ہے اور اگلی 2، 3 trades بغیر setup کے ہو جاتی ہیں۔ حل: ہر trade میں account کا ایک ہی فیصد risk (1 سے 2 فیصد)، اور دن میں زیادہ سے زیادہ 2 یا 3 trades۔
3۔ ہر support، resistance اور OB پر trade: ہر level trade کے قابل نہیں ہوتا۔ حل: صرف وہ level لیں جو HTF trend کے ساتھ ہو، اور وہاں M5 یا M15 پر rejection یا MSS کا انتظار کریں۔
سب سے ضروری کام: پچھلی 30 trades کا journal بنائیں: entry کی وجہ، SL، RR، lot، اور نتیجہ۔ پھر دیکھیں loss والی trades میں کون سی غلطی بار بار ہے۔ اپ کا اصل علاج اسی list میں ہو گا۔
اپ کا cent account پر رہنا اچھا فیصلہ ہے، جب تک 2 سے 3 مہینے مسلسل profit نہ ہو، وہیں رہیں۔
What "profit, then give it back" really means
If you have winning days at all, your entries are not random. What is happening is that the average loss is bigger than the average win, or that a few bad trades after a good run wipe out the gains. It is the same pattern as in "my strategy works, so why am I not consistently profitable?": the leak is in the size of the losses, not in the setups.
Cause 1: small wins, big losses
Many traders close winners early to "lock in" profit, but let losers run, hoping they will come back. Over a month that is enough to turn a 60% win rate into a loss. The fix is mechanical: decide the stop loss before entry, never move it further away, and aim for a target at least twice the stop (risk-reward of 1:2). With 1:2, you stay profitable even if only four trades in ten win.
Cause 2: bigger lots and more trades after a win
A good day brings confidence, and the next two or three trades are often taken with a bigger lot or without a full setup. That is where the week's profit goes. Keep the risk the same percentage of the account on every trade, 1 to 2%, and calculate the lot from the stop distance each time (how to calculate lot size). Add a daily limit, for example a maximum of two or three trades, or stop after two losses.
Cause 3: every level becomes a trade
Support, resistance and order blocks appear everywhere on a Gold chart. Trading all of them means many trades against the higher-timeframe trend. Filter them: take only levels that agree with the H4 or daily trend, and at the level wait for a rejection or a market structure shift on M5 or M15 before entering.
| Leak | How it shows in the journal | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Small wins, big losses | Average loss larger than average win | Fixed stop, target at least 2x the stop |
| Bigger lots after wins | Lot size changes from trade to trade | Same % risk on every trade, daily trade limit |
| Every level traded | Many losses against the H4/daily trend | Only levels with the trend, wait for confirmation |
Find your own leak in 30 trades
Write down your last 30 trades: the reason for entry, stop, risk-reward, lot size and result. Then sort the losing trades. In almost every case one mistake repeats, and that single mistake is the fix. A ready template is in our free trading journal. Staying on a cent account until you have two or three profitable months in a row is the right decision.
Khulasa (Roman Urdu / Hindi)
- Profit ke din aate hain to entries mein dam hai; masla loss ke size mein hai.
- Pehli wajah: profit jaldi band, loss lamba chalana. Hal: SL fix, RR kam az kam 1:2, SL kabhi peeche nahi.
- Doosri wajah: jeet ke baad bara lot ya zyada trades. Hal: har trade mein 1-2% risk, din mein 2-3 trades.
- Teesri wajah: har level par trade. Hal: sirf HTF trend wale level, wahan M5/M15 confirmation.
- Pichli 30 trades ka journal: bar bar wali ghalti hi asal ilaj hai.
- 2-3 mahine mustaqil profit tak cent account par rahein.
Questions
Why do I give back my profits after a few days?
Usually because losses are larger than wins, lot size grows after a winning run, or too many low-quality levels are traded. The journal shows which one.
What risk-reward should I use?
Aim for at least 1:2. Then you stay profitable even if only four trades in ten win.
How much should I risk per trade?
The same 1 to 2% of the account on every trade, with the lot calculated from the stop distance.
Should I move to a standard account?
Only after two or three months of consistent profit on a cent or small account.
اکثر پوچھے جانے والے سوال
پرافٹ کر کے واپس کیوں چلا جاتا ہے؟
اکثر لاس بڑے اور پرافٹ چھوٹے ہوتے ہیں، یا جیت کے بعد لاٹ بڑا ہو جاتا ہے۔
کتنا رسک لیں؟
ہر ٹریڈ میں اکاؤنٹ کا ایک سے دو فیصد، ہر بار ایک جیسا۔
اپنی غلطی کیسے پکڑیں؟
پچھلی 30 ٹریڈز کا جرنل بنائیں اور لاس والی ٹریڈز میں بار بار کی غلطی دیکھیں۔
Aksar Pooche Jane Wale Sawal (Roman Urdu / Hindi)
Profit wapas kyun chala jata hai?
Loss bara aur profit chhota, ya jeet ke baad bara lot.
RR kitna rakhein?
Kam az kam 1:2.
Cent account kab chhorein?
Jab 2-3 mahine mustaqil profit ho.
Learn more
- My strategy works, so why am I not consistently profitable?
- Risk-reward ratio
- How to calculate lot size
- Risk management in forex
- Good back-test, but overtrading live
- Free trading journal for MT5
Have a question of your own, or a chart you want checked? Post it with your reasoning in our free Facebook group.
Join the free groupEducation only, not financial advice. Trading forex, Gold and CFDs carries a high risk of loss. Spreads, leverage and contract sizes differ by broker; check your own broker's specifications.
Qazi Forex Tips