H1 OB ki liquidity pick hui aur momentum candle close hui, lekin 1st tap tha aur SL bhi high aur risky tha. M1 ki confirmation par 1st entry li aur M5 ki closing par 2nd entry, half risk M1 par aur baqi half M5 par. (Sajid Haneef ka trade journal)
رسک کو دو انٹریز میں کیسے بانٹیں؟
ماشاءاللہ ساجد بھائی، یہ والا جرنل تو سکھانے والا ہے۔ سب سے اچھی بات یہ لگی کہ پہلے ٹیپ پر سٹاپ بڑا تھا تو آپ نے رسک دو حصوں میں بانٹ دیا: آدھا ایک منٹ کی کنفرمیشن پر اور آدھا پانچ منٹ کی کلوزنگ پر۔ اس سے غلط ہونے کی صورت میں نقصان آدھا رہتا ہے۔
ممبرز کے لیے دو باتیں اور:
1۔ رسک تقسیم کرنے کا مطلب یہ ہے کہ دونوں انٹریز ملا کر بھی کل رسک ایک فیصد سے زیادہ نہ ہو، یعنی دوسری انٹری اضافی رسک نہیں بلکہ اسی رسک کا باقی حصہ ہو۔
2۔ ٹرینڈ کے خلاف سکیلپنگ ٹریڈز میں ٹارگٹ چھوٹا رکھیں اور جلدی بریک ایون کریں، کیونکہ بڑا ٹرینڈ کسی بھی وقت واپس آ سکتا ہے۔
اور کل کی بریک ایون والی بات بالکل صحیح ہے، بریک ایون لاس نہیں ہوتا، یہ اکاؤنٹ بچانے کا فائدہ ہے۔
Why split the entry at all
The first touch of a fresh zone, such as an H1 order block, often gives the best reaction, but it also often needs a wide stop: the zone is tall and you do not yet know where inside it price will turn. Taking the full position at the first sign of a reaction means a full loss if the zone fails. Waiting for a clean M5 close is safer but sometimes means missing the move.
Splitting the entry is the middle way. You enter half on the earliest confirmation (an M1 shift or rejection) and the other half only if the next confirmation (the M5 candle close) agrees. If the zone fails early, you lose half. If it works, you are fully in with both halves.
The one rule that keeps it safe
The second entry is not extra risk. Decide your total risk first, normally 1% of the account (see risk management in forex), then divide it. With a $1,000 account and a 1% plan, that is $10 in total: $5 on the first entry and $5 on the second, with the stop in the same place below the zone. Work out each lot size from the stop distance, as in how to calculate lot size.
| Example ($1,000 account, 1% plan) | Entry 1 (M1 confirmation) | Entry 2 (M5 close) | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Risk | $5 | $5 | $10 (1%) |
| If the zone fails before entry 2 | -$5 | not taken | -$5 (0.5%) |
| If both fill and the stop is hit | -$5 | -$5 | -$10 (1%) |
Where this goes wrong
- Adding to a loser. Splitting an entry is planned before the trade. Adding a second position because the first is in loss is averaging down, and it is how accounts blow up.
- Moving the stop. Both entries share one stop, decided before entry. Do not widen it to "make room" for the second entry.
- Counter-trend scalps. When the setup is against the higher-timeframe trend, keep the target small and move to breakeven early, as in trading against the trend.
Breakeven is not a loss
The member also noted that two earlier trades in the trend direction went to breakeven. That is the system working: a breakeven exit protects the account while the setup proves itself. Record it in your trading journal as a protected trade, not a failed one.
Khulasa (Roman Urdu / Hindi)
- SL bara ho to poori position ek saath lene ke bajaye risk do hisson mein baantein.
- Aadha risk pehli confirmation (M1) par, baqi aadha agli confirmation (M5 closing) par.
- Dono entries mila kar bhi kul risk 1% se zyada na ho. Doosri entry extra risk nahi, usi risk ka baqi hissa hai.
- Dono entries ka SL ek hi jagah, trade se pehle tay. Loss mein jaati trade mein add karna averaging hai, woh nahi karna.
- Trend ke khilaf scalping mein target chhota aur breakeven jaldi.
- Breakeven loss nahi, account bachane ka faida hai.
Questions
What does splitting risk into two entries mean?
Taking half of your planned risk on the first confirmation and the other half on a second confirmation, with one shared stop loss, so a failed setup costs only half.
Is the second entry extra risk?
No. Decide the total risk first, usually 1% of the account, and divide it between the two entries.
Is this the same as averaging down?
No. A split entry is planned before the trade and both parts share one stop. Adding to a losing trade without a plan is averaging down.
When is a split entry useful?
When the stop is wide, such as the first touch of a fresh order block, and you want to reduce the loss if the zone fails.
اکثر پوچھے جانے والے سوال
رسک دو انٹریز میں بانٹنے کا کیا مطلب ہے؟
پلان کیا ہوا رسک آدھا آدھا دو کنفرمیشنز پر لینا، اور دونوں کا سٹاپ لاس ایک ہی جگہ رکھنا۔
کیا دوسری انٹری اضافی رسک ہے؟
نہیں، دونوں انٹریز ملا کر کل رسک ایک فیصد ہی رہنا چاہیے۔
کیا یہ ایوریجنگ ہے؟
نہیں، ایوریجنگ لاس والی ٹریڈ میں بغیر پلان کے اضافہ ہے۔ یہاں سب کچھ ٹریڈ سے پہلے طے ہوتا ہے۔
Aksar Pooche Jane Wale Sawal (Roman Urdu / Hindi)
Risk do entries mein kaise baantein?
Kul risk pehle tay karein, maslan 1%, phir aadha pehli confirmation par aur aadha agli closing par lein, SL dono ka ek.
Doosri entry kab na lein?
Agar pehli confirmation ke baad price zone se bahar close kar de ya setup ki wajah khatam ho jaye.
Breakeven trade ko kya samjhein?
Loss nahi, account bachane ka faida. Journal mein protected trade likhein.
Learn more
- Risk management in forex
- How to calculate lot size
- What is an order block
- Trading against the trend
- Managing a trade when you are away from the screen
- Free trading journal for MT5
Have a question of your own, or a chart you want checked? Post it with your reasoning in our free Facebook group.
Join the free groupEducation only, not financial advice. Trading forex, Gold and CFDs carries a high risk of loss. Spreads, leverage and contract sizes differ by broker; check your own broker's specifications.
Qazi Forex Tips