Qazi Forex Tips logoQazi Forex Tips
Sawal Jawab · Risk management

My strategy works, so why am I not consistently profitable?

A member shared his trading calendar: most days were green at +$20 to +$33, but three red days of -$30, -$57 and -$57 wiped out the week. He asked why a strategy that works is not consistently profitable. The calendar itself gives the answer: the problem is the size of the losses, not the entries.

Trading calendar bar chart: green days of +20 to +33 dollars and red days of -30 and -57 dollars, showing one bad day equals two good days; 4 fixes: fixed risk, daily loss limit, no recovery lots, check the journal
Ek bura din do achay din kha jata hai: pehle risk theek karein, phir strategy.
The question from the group

I'm stuck at a point in my trading journey. My strategy works, but I haven't been able to make it consistently profitable yet. Any suggestions or advice from experienced traders?

Dr. Qazi Abdul Basit
Dr. Qazi's answerIn Urdu, as answered in the group

اسٹریٹیجی ٹھیک ہے تو پرافٹ کنسسٹنٹ کیوں نہیں؟

جی بھائی، آپ کا کیلنڈر خود بتا رہا ہے کہ مسئلہ اسٹریٹیجی میں نہیں، رسک میں ہے:

1۔ جیتنے والے دن 20 سے 33 ڈالر کے ہیں اور ہارنے والے دن 57 ڈالر کے۔ یعنی ایک برا دن تقریباً دو اچھے دن کھا جاتا ہے۔

2۔ ہر ٹریڈ کا رسک فکس کریں (مثلاً اکاؤنٹ کا ایک فیصد) اور دن کا میکسیمم لاس بھی طے کریں، دو لاس کے بعد اس دن ٹریڈنگ بند۔

3۔ لاس کے بعد اگلی ٹریڈ میں لاٹ بڑھا کر ریکور کرنے والا طریقہ نہ اپنائیں، یہ کچھ دن چلتا ہے پھر لاس کی ایک سیریز اکاؤنٹ کو بہت نقصان دیتی ہے۔

4۔ پچھلی پچاس ٹریڈز کا جرنل دیکھیں کہ ایوریج لاس ایوریج پرافٹ سے بڑا کیوں ہے: اسٹاپ لاس دور ہے یا پرافٹ جلدی بند کر رہے ہیں۔

یہ دو چیزیں ٹھیک ہو گئیں تو یہی اسٹریٹیجی کنسسٹنٹ ہو جائے گی ان شاء اللہ۔

Read the calendar like a risk report

Add up the member's ten days: seven green days made about $175, three red days lost $144. The strategy wins 70% of the days, yet the week is almost flat. That is the classic sign of an average loss bigger than the average win. With $25 average wins and $48 average losses, you need roughly two winning days to pay for every losing day. One more bad day and the month turns red, even though "the strategy works".

Fix 1: risk the same amount on every trade

Decide a fixed risk per trade, for example 1% of the account, and let the lot size come from the stop loss distance. Then a loss is always the same size and can never be a surprise. The method is in our risk management guide, and the QFT Trade Assistant calculates the lot for you in MT5.

Fix 2: a daily loss limit

Most big red days are not one bad trade but two or three trades taken after the first loss. Set a rule such as "two losses and I stop for the day". It caps the worst day and protects you from revenge trading. See trading psychology.

Fix 3: never increase the lot to recover a loss

A common tip is to make the next trade bigger so its profit covers the last loss. It works for a few days because most strategies win more often than they lose. Then a normal losing streak of four or five trades arrives, each trade bigger than the last, and one series does the damage of a month. A fixed risk survives a losing streak; a recovery lot does not. See what drawdown means.

Fix 4: let the journal tell you why losses are bigger

Pull the last 50 trades and compare the average loss with the average win. If the stop loss is too wide, tighten the entry. If profits are closed early out of fear, set a fixed target such as 1:2 and leave it. Our free MT5 trading journal shows these numbers automatically. For the target side, read risk to reward explained.

Khulasa (Roman Urdu / Hindi)

  • Jeetne wale din 20-33 dollar, haarne wale din 57 dollar: aik bura din do achay din kha jata hai.
  • Har trade ka risk fix karein, maslan account ka 1%, aur lot size SL se nikalein.
  • Din ki loss limit: do loss ke baad us din trading band.
  • Loss ke baad lot barha kar recover karne wala tareeqa na apnayein.
  • Pichli 50 trades ka journal dekhein ke average loss average profit se bara kyun hai.

Questions

Why is my strategy not profitable even with a high win rate?

Because the average loss is bigger than the average win. A 70% win rate can still break even if each loss is about twice the size of each win.

Should I increase my lot after a loss to recover it?

No. It works until a normal losing streak arrives, and then each bigger trade makes the drawdown much deeper. Keep the risk per trade fixed.

What is a good daily loss limit?

Many traders stop after two losing trades or after losing 2% of the account in a day. The exact number matters less than following it every day.

How do I find out why my losses are bigger than my wins?

Check the last 50 trades in a journal: compare stop distance with target distance and see whether profits are closed early.

اکثر پوچھے جانے والے سوال

ون ریٹ اچھا ہے پھر بھی پرافٹ کیوں نہیں؟

کیونکہ ایوریج لاس ایوریج پرافٹ سے بڑا ہے۔ ایک برا دن دو اچھے دن کھا جاتا ہے۔

لاس کے بعد لاٹ بڑھا کر ریکور کریں؟

نہیں۔ لگاتار لاس کی ایک سیریز میں یہی طریقہ اکاؤنٹ کو بہت نقصان دیتا ہے۔

دن میں کتنے لاس کے بعد رک جائیں؟

عام طور پر دو لاس کے بعد اس دن ٹریڈنگ بند کر دیں۔

Aksar Pooche Jane Wale Sawal (Roman Urdu / Hindi)

Strategy chal rahi hai phir bhi profit kyun nahi?

Average loss average profit se bara hai, is liye risk theek karein.

Loss ke baad lot barhayein?

Nahi, risk har trade par fix rakhein.

Daily loss limit kya rakhein?

Do loss ke baad us din band.

Learn more

Have a question of your own, or a chart you want checked? Post it with your reasoning in our free Facebook group.

Join the free group

Education only, not financial advice. Trading forex, Gold and CFDs carries a high risk of loss. Spreads, leverage and contract sizes differ by broker; check your own broker's specifications.