Qazi Forex Tips logoQazi Forex Tips
SMC Course · Phase 7 · Lesson 7.2

Trading Journal

A journal is a trader's mirror. A trader who does not write things down repeats the same mistake and believes the market is against them. In this lesson you will learn what to record, how to run a weekly review, and how to use the journal to find your most expensive mistake.

Trading journal in 3D: desk with a Gold chart and a journal sheet with entry, stop, target and result in R

Why a journal?

  • Memory lies: we remember winners and forget mistakes. The journal tells the truth.
  • Mistake patterns: after 50 trades the journal shows where most of your losses come from: bad timing, weak POIs, early entries or oversized lots.
  • Confidence: in a losing streak the journal reminds you that your system has recovered from streaks like this before.

Seven fields per trade

Trading journal template with seven fields per trade and a Gold example
The seven fields of a trading journal, with a Gold trade example.
  1. Date and session: which day and which killzone.
  2. Bias and DOL: the higher timeframe bias and the target liquidity.
  3. Model and POI score: model A, B, C, D or E, and the scorecard number.
  4. Entry, SL, TP and lot: the numbers and the RR.
  5. Result in R: not dollars, R, so trades compare across account and lot sizes.
  6. Emotions: how you felt before and during the trade (calm, rushed, angry, bored).
  7. Lesson: one line: what went well, what could be better.

Plus two screenshots: at entry and after the close.

RememberFor every trade answer one question with yes or no: "Did I follow my rules 100%?" This is the most important field. A losing trade that followed the rules is a good trade; a winning trade that broke them is a bad one.

Which tool?

ToolAdvantageDisadvantage
QFT Trading Coach (our free MT5 journal)Free; reads your MT5 history automatically, finds 9 trading mistakes and their cost, grades every trade, English and Urdu reportsMT5 only; you still note your entry reason and emotions yourself
Excel or Google SheetsFree, custom fields, your own formulasScreenshots kept separately
Paper notebookWriting helps memoryHard to calculate and filter
Journal software or websiteImports trades from MT5, chartsOften paid

Our advice: if you trade on MT5, download the free QFT Trading Coach; it does the maths and finds your mistakes for you. Keep each trade's reason and screenshot in a small Google Sheet alongside it. More important than the tool is recording every trade, losers included.

Weekly review (Sunday, 30 minutes)

  1. Total R, win rate and average RR for the week.
  2. How many trades followed the rules? (Target: 90% or more)
  3. The single biggest mistake.
  4. One goal for next week, for example "no trades in the 30 minutes before news".
  5. Next week's news times in your time zone (lesson 4.4).

Find your most expensive mistake

After 50 trades, filter the journal:

FilterQuestion
SessionWhich killzone is negative?
POI scoreWhat is the result of trades scoring below 8?
EmotionsWhat about trades marked "rushed" or "angry"?
RulesTotal R of rule-breaking trades?
DayIs one day (say Friday) consistently bad?

Most traders find that most of their losses come from a few types of mistake, such as bored night trading or taking another trade right after a loss. Stopping one or two of these often changes the result.

Gold example: one month's review

24 trades in a month, total +5.2R:

  • Following the rules: 18 trades, +11.4R.
  • Breaking the rules: 6 trades (4 near news, 2 right after a loss), −6.2R.
  • Result: with only rule-following trades the month would have been +11.4R, about 11% at 1% risk. Next month's goal: "No trades 30 minutes before news, and a one-hour break after a loss."

Real Gold chart examples

The journal entry for the 27 Oct 2026 model A trade (lessons 5.2 and 6.2), Gold M15 (data: Dukascopy, bid price; Pakistan time):

The journal screenshot: sweep, entry, TP1 and exit.
The journal screenshot: sweep, entry, TP1 and exit.
FieldEntry
Date and sessionTuesday 27 Oct; sweep in the London killzone, entry in the New York killzone
Bias and DOLH4 CRT (candle 2 swept the low); DOL first the PDH at 4,029.7
Model and POI scoreModel A; score 8/10 (HTF bias only from the CRT, no clear H4 trend)
Entry, SL, TP, lot4,019.9 / 4,009.5 / TP1 4,029.7 / 0.04 lot (1% of $5,000)
Result+2.2R
Rules followed 100%?Yes; did not chase when the first FVG was missed
EmotionsRestless after missing the first FVG, but waited
LessonThe sweep was next to the PDL: two liquidity levels together give a stronger reaction

Every trade should be logged like this, losers too, so patterns show up after 50 trades.

Second example: a winning trade, a broken rule (22 Oct)

The journal entry for the 22 Oct 2026 model A sell (the second examples in lessons 5.2 and 6.2), Gold M15 (data: Dukascopy, bid price; Pakistan time):

The journal screenshot: sweep, entry and TP1.
The journal screenshot: sweep, entry and TP1.
FieldEntry
Date and sessionThursday 22 Oct; sweep at 03:00, entry at 07:30 (Asian killzone)
Bias and DOLH4 bearish (LH after LH); DOL the night low at 4,104.6
Model and POI scoreModel A; score 7/10 (entry below the 50% at 4,126.4, in discount)
Entry, SL, TP, lot4,121.2 / 4,128.5 / TP1 4,104.6 / 0.06 lot (1% of $5,000)
Result+3.1R
Rules followed 100%?No: a score of 7 means half risk; full risk was taken
EmotionsRestless after missing the first FVG; a "must take this one" rush
LessonThe rule broke despite the win; half risk on a B setup

This entry matters because the trade won but a rule was broken. By lesson 7.2 that is a bad trade; if it is not logged honestly, the same habit will cost full risk on tomorrow's losing trade.

Common mistakes

Common mistakeRecording only winners. The biggest lessons are in the losers.
Common mistakeRecording results in dollars instead of R. Changing lot sizes makes dollar comparisons wrong.
Common mistakeWriting a journal and never reading it. Without a weekly review a journal is just a diary.

Summary

  • Seven fields and two screenshots per trade; the key one: "100% rule adherence?"
  • Record results in R.
  • A 30-minute review every Sunday with one goal for the next week.
  • After 50 trades, filter to find your most expensive mistake and stop it.

Free downloads

Print them or keep them on your phone. No sign-up, no email.

Trading Journal Sheet (Excel)

Trading Journal Sheet (Excel)

One row per trade with dropdowns and automatic maths: win rate, total R, expectancy, drawdown, results by session and emotion, weekly review. Works in Excel and Google Sheets.

Free downloadاردو میں

Try this lesson on your own chart

Qazi Forex Tips' own tools that make this lesson easier. A tool helps; your rules make the decision.

QFT Trading Coach (journal)

100% free · MT5

Reads your MT5 history automatically, finds 9 trading mistakes and what each one cost, grades every trade and saves English and Urdu reports.

Details and download

Spot it on the chart: practice

This is a real Gold chart (Dukascopy data, Pakistan time). Study it and pick an answer. After you answer, the fully marked chart and the explanation appear.

Question chart
Question chart

A trader bought at 4,214.9 on the 17:30 candle on 30 Sep (the 8:30 New York release), SL 4,206.9. How should this trade go in the journal?

Test yourself: Lesson 7.2 quiz

8 questions. Pick one answer for each and you will see at once whether it is right and why. Your score and grade appear at the end. You need 70% to pass.

0 correct · 0 / 8

  1. Question 1Why is a journal necessary?

  2. Question 2Why record results in R rather than dollars?

  3. Question 3What is the most important journal field?

  4. Question 4How many screenshots per trade?

  5. Question 5In the weekly review, what is the rule-following target?

  6. Question 6After 50 trades, what do traders usually find?

  7. Question 7One month: 24 trades, +5.2R; 18 rule-following trades +11.4R, 6 rule-breaking trades −6.2R. The lesson?

  8. Question 8What about writing a journal and never reading it?

Lesson checklist

Tick each point once you understand it. Your ticks are saved in this browser.

Assignment

  1. Build a seven-field journal in Google Sheets, plus a "rules followed" field.
  2. Enter your last 20 trades (or backtest).
  3. Calculate the total R of rule-following and rule-breaking trades separately.
  4. Filter by session and POI score.
  5. Post your most expensive mistake and next week's goal in the group.

Post your assignment screenshots with your reasons in our free Facebook group, where your charts will be checked.

Join the free group
Dr. Qazi Abdul Basit

Who wrote this lesson

, Ph.D

Ph.D in Business Administration and a forex and Gold trader since 2013. Founder of Qazi Forex Tips, which teaches traders in Pakistan and India price action, risk management and trading psychology in their own language: 65 student batches so far, free courses on YouTube, and MT5 tools for traders (QFT Replay Simulator, QFT Trade Assistant).

  • 2013 trading since
  • 75K+ Facebook group members
  • 65 student batches
  • 15K+ YouTube subscribers

How this lesson was made: the content follows Dr. Qazi's teaching method and years of trading. Real charts are built from Dukascopy Gold (XAUUSD) data, and backtest results are shown as they came out, even when negative. We do not sell signals, manage accounts or take money from any broker. Last updated: 19 November 2026.

Full profile · YouTube · Facebook group · Student feedback

Questions

What should a trading journal include?

Date and session, bias and draw on liquidity, model and POI score, entry, stop, target and lot, result in R, emotions, a lesson, and before and after screenshots.

Why record results in R?

R makes trades comparable regardless of account size and lot size.

How often should I review my journal?

Every week, for example 30 minutes on Sunday, plus a detailed filter every 50 trades.

Where can I get a free trading journal?

There are two free options on this page: our Excel journal sheet (it does the maths) and QFT Trading Coach for MT5, which reads your history and finds your mistakes.

Can I keep the journal in Google Sheets?

Yes, open our Excel sheet in Google Sheets with File > Import; the formulas and dropdowns work there too.

Read more

Education only, not financial advice. Trading forex, Gold and CFDs carries a high risk of loss. SMC concepts describe tendencies, not guarantees. Lesson 36 of 38.